| Forums > General > "Comments/Score of Last Summer Competition Entries" (28 replies)
|
|
|
Judges posts your comments here.
We will get a winner when you have the average marks.
the banners are roughly finished. so inkSPLASH, i've finished my comments.
your turn 
Edited 15 days ago. |
| |
|
| |
|
| |
The Summer Diaries [Slayerette]
Submission
Theme (18.5 over 20)
The vintage feel of the blogskin is really nice and it really does give off a kind of
"dairy" looking feel. Title is sustained prominently throughout. and this is really lovely.
Diary skins are really better for navigations, and thus it is a very good choice you have
made, you give me the nice vintage-ish feeling from your skin and really shows like how
summer is  commendable!
Codes (17.5 over 20)
CSS is really super neat. (really). any idea why you have three s ? no closing
of </body> tag. other than that, it's neat.
Design (47 over 50)
color combination: speechless.
use of frames(polariod like) and creativity. wonderful.
Effort (10 over 10)
Effort seen. bravo (see i told you it's so easy to score)
93/100
Edited 15 days ago. |
| |
| |
|
| |
summer.love- icecool
Submission
Theme (15 over 20)
Look, I really love this fresh idea and it's really nice but it's really confusing. the
background is really love, and some more it can be "changable". To me those pictures fit
the theme (yes they do) so i think it's somehow rather okay.
Codes (12 over 20)
CSS is WOW. but it's a bit "messy" here and there but overall it's really good.
Design (35 over 50)
concept-fresh. (wonderful). navigation is really cool and it's pretty interesting.
Color Combination of the black background is good but let's just say the pictures don't
really blend it. (or are they not supposed to blend in)
Effort (8 over 10)
70/100
|
| |
| |
|
| |
sugar.rush♥ ___#2. memories of last summer.
Submission
Theme (16.5 over 20)
Image Choice depicts sences at the beach. The Light Feel is really soothing. Good theme:
Memories of Last Summer. Yes. But I suggest maybe if you want like have some polariods ?
for memories. That's my opinon otherwise flimstrips? so I liked it lots.
Codes (12 over 20)
quite organized codes and normal in the sense. Average Codes. but it's really good though.
Design (38 over 50)
Concept-quite unfresh already but still has its foothold in designing blogskins. I think
the profile shouldn't be so big to the extent it is 1/2 of the entries. I'd rather you make
the entries look bigger. Color Combination Is really smart. I love the color combination
(really). Overall. It is nice ♥
Effort (9 over 10)
Effort is seen but maybe in another perception. If you want my deduce of these effort
marks, get it from me
75.5/100
|
| |
| |
|
| |
!mrMILO.king(5)-its-cold
Submission
Theme (17.5 over 20)
It gives a really gloom picture of summer. Yes. That is what i want. THINKOUTOFTHEBOX. I
hinted like music romance and stuff. but this is totally creative. Joseph used dull colors
to convey message of "greenhouse effect" and global warming. His layout theme is superb!
and the polariods serve as a purpose like telling us about the future that can only
remember our past and not feel it (about the trees) and stuff. which is really scarce due
to more and more industralisation. Personally, I like it creating awarness and also act as
a blogskin.
Codes (19 over 20)
Very Clean Cut.
note: <title></title>TheLastSummer- this code is wrong. (haha) Very clear
codes.
Design (44 over 50)
Concept- NICE. Polariods touch- Love. Color Combination for links could be better. Overall
(:
Effort (9 over 10)
It's really too nice. Dully Nicely Matched!
89.5/100
|
| |
| |
|
| |
R.P.`Summer Diary #01
Submission
Theme (17 over 20)
Light Feel. Summer Diary (common theme). See you have expressed it in terms of fading
memories but made it seem really light and nice. By The way, this theme is really
expressing lots of random things, like a lot of things are going on (i don't see much stuff
in the image).
Codes (19 over 20)
3 Words to describe: Short, Precise, Loved.
I wonder why the >head< stretches from the top to the bottom of it.
Design (40 over 50)
I love the color combination of the Orangy-Brown for the title. The link color combinations
are pretty cool too. Try blending in more of same models/series pictures instead of random
love pictures cause so much thign is going on and i don't know what to feel.
Effort (9.5 over 10)
Effort is shown clear, precise. and it's a precious piece of art.
85.5/100
|
| |
| |
|
| |
paperlove♥/Crazy Summer
Submission
Theme (19.5 over 20)
Bold Idea. Bold Theme. That's what i like that kinky feel of that title. The Theme is just
really bold, yes. I hope you feel the same way too.
Codes (20 over 20)
Nicely put in a way, organized structure of codes.
Oh yes, and it's ♥/ Neat!
Design (48.5 over 50)
Color Combinations sure are your forte. I like the way the layout is organized and simply
put in such a way that it is mesmerising. Your New CONCEPT of the pattern at the side is
really unique and nevertheless if detonatedlove says this layout is bad, I think it is One
Of the best. Good use of series pictures from foto_decadent, really potraying summer. The
colors are really mesmerising (for the photos). Good usage of brushes as well. The quote is
unique too, really fitting.
Effort (10 over 10)
Effort Seen! Chopped and ready to go, for an envelope package with a seal of wax.
98/100
Edited 15 days ago. |
| |
| |
|
| |
18. Summer Love ; Hasegawa-san
Submission
Theme (18 over 20)
Summer Love Summer Summer Summer. That's all about americans finding a love (like
flirting) haha. Sustainable Summer Love Theme. Stylish Image of the model, the choice of
the model waiting really potrays a "waiting of love" feeling. so It's really quite
Codes (17 over 20)
Simple. Neat. Though you used basecodes for help.
Design (40 over 50)
Color Combinations are daring. That's your best point. The image seems pixalated and
outlines of a few images are prominent. I still think there is improvement. Overall Light
feel and Summer Love is there.
Effort (9.5 over 10)
Whistles.
84.5/100
|
| |
| |
|
| |
1{justfeelsogood; -thesockparody.
Submission
Theme (17 over 20)
Well what does it mean by justfeelssogood. issit summer that make you feel that way. Let's
just say think about it that way. yes, It gives bright feel, and sunshine like, though it
was really like. Colorfully done, and really makes us feel very good!
Codes (16 over 20)
Codes are little messy here and there, though you used basecodes from YeLing
Design (41 over 50)
Color Combinations. i have to hail you. It's really combined nicely. The brushes were used
carefully. definetly not a brush spam and it's really concise and delievers the message.
Everything just fits in place. justfeelssogood.
Effort (9.5 over 10)
justfeelssogood.
83.5/100
|
| |
| |
|
| |
RC.R♥ - We had fun in the sun }07
Submission
Theme (16 over 20)
Well. Fun in the sun i considered that nice. but some of the pictures a little too
towards that color you wanted it to have so it made it somewhat look funny. and little out.
Colorful and depicts fun in the sun, good choice of theme and good choice of pictures.
Sustainable.
Codes (15 over 20)
CSS are defintely wonderful. Content codes are little little frenzy and messy.
Though some part of the codes were taken from basecodes.
Design (37 over 50)
I like the color combinations as well. tries to make pictures look colorful and attempt was
quite successful. It pulled off.
Effort (8.5 over 10)
It's really good, no doubt and it's a high mark for effort seen already for using the
editing in GIMP.
76.5/100
|
| |
| |
|
| |
SUMMER LOVE - Lady-Nadya
Submission
Theme (14 over 20)
Choice of Theme to fit the blogskin. Good. Excellent. Choose one. but I don't really see
any sustaining of summer love in the blogskin. Is there hint of summer love apart from the
title. I admit it is very good But no relation to theme you chose.
Codes (15.5 over 20)
Wonderful Codes from basecoder kynzgerl. (i have to deduct marks for using basecodes)
Design (40 over 50)
Brushes made the blogskin gradually fit in. Light color combinations are well done. Thumbs
up. The image are cropped properly and is okay.
Effort (8 over 10)
Looks Away. Sorry
79.5/100
|
| |
| |
|
| |
Summer (: by wat-u-wan-to-say
Submission
Theme (17 over 20)
Vague Title. Image carries most of the idea. Yes The inspiration and concept fresh.
Sustainable. I love the way this title makes the suspense more and really it's nice.
Codes (19 over 20)
Wonderful Neat Codes that are totally organized. Precise.
Design (42 over 50)
these skins are common, but your image is special. I feel somewhat like that line / quote
is more than cliche. the colors in the image is really special. Color combination is
Effort (9 over 10)
Chopped and Sealed.
87/100
|
| |
| |
|
| |
{/al♥ [21] last summer.
Submission
Theme (17.5 over 20)
Yes, you used the competition name; Last Summer. See how you fared for sustaining it
Codes (18 over 20)
Neat.
Design (38 over 50)
Pixalated Images. Overall Fine.
Effort (10 over 10)
Best Originality for using own images.
83.5/100
|
| |
| |
|
| |
tealightcandles [ #04 | lastsummer. thenecklace ]
Submission
Theme (13 over 20)
Nostalgia type (thenecklace) not seen prominently though it's small and it's in the
picture. Creative. But unable to sustain much.
Codes (18 over 20)
Clean Cut, Neat and there is no overlap or stuff.
Design (30 over 50)
Pixalated Images. Work on Image Quality. color combination was slightly off. sorry.
Effort (8.5 over 10)
Looks away.
69.5/100
|
| |
| |
|
| |
XSTACY break a part.
Submission
Theme (16 over 20)
In "break a part" see no relevance. But maybe it's about love, and this girl's heart is
broken apart. so it's guess so time. So regarding that. Yes. Lots of Summer Stuff.
Codes (20 over 20)
Loved it.
Design (43 over 50)
Notepad Image. I didn't know you're so creative and textures with splats are really nice.
New concept i've never seen before. It made it diary like and pictures are really fitting.
Liked how it turned out.
Effort (9 over 10)
Looks away.
88/100
|
| |
| |
|
| |
kml} last summer's memories,
Submission
Theme (17 over 20)
Memories again. Nostalgic and the background seems a little too daring. Made it dullish
(maybe that's memories of summer) your perception. Sustainable Topic.
Codes (16 over 20)
Codes are little messy here and there. hope your codes are really yours though. overall
it's a nice masterpiece of codes
Design (44 over 50)
OMG! i like the quote: "memories fade to grey" really nice. gave me the flimstrip kind of
thing that i really liked. I adore the colors a lot. It's a nice try of the splat kind of
masking. good try. creative idea. really. Color Combinations are refreshing rainbow-like.
Effort (9.5 over 10)
Good Try
86.5/100
|
| |
|
| |
|
| |
#40 Summer Reminiscences; } LIX!
Submission
Theme (18.5 over 20)
Memories. Little random here and there in the dairy but it of course could sustain well enough.
Codes (18.5 over 20)
No Comment.
Design (48 over 50)
Light and Nice Color Combinations. Dull Pictures in contrast. Refreshing The random
stuff like Deaniee is crazy or what is a little "i don't get what you mean" kind of thing.
The Diary Concept is like really many abstract ideas that fit into one. I get what you mean
like a real diary kind of thing for a girl. The idea is just a little too random :X
Effort (9.5 over 10)
Rining of Gongs, Drum rolls. Lay the red carpet on the floor.
94.5/100
Edited 15 days ago. |
| |
| |
|
| |
lols? slayerette has a landslide victory
|
| |
| |
|
| |
for some reason, i always thought there were more submissions.
|
| |
| |
|
| |
slayerette - blogskins.com/info/178486
i love the soft warm colours used in the image. It really depicts the summer feeling into the skin. However, i would want to see a different type of codings rather than your usual Century Gothic headers, dashed bottom borders etc.
85/100
icecool - blogskins.com/info/178623
At first glance, i am really confuse with the layout since everything is rather messy. The image is blocked and would change every few seconds. I would have prefer if the image is fixed at a certain position where it is visible. I dont see how black and green actually relate to the theme, brighter colours would be nice. The posts area is a little too wide and the search box is rather unnecessary in my opinion. On a positive note though, i like the fact that its compatible to all screen resolutions and the collapse effect of the profile is wicked cool!!
74/100
!sugar.rush - blogskins.com/info/178783
i love how you blended the image together but a few floral brush would beautify it more. codings are fine, just a little alignment problem in firefox. and i think it would have look better if you loose the scrollbars!
74/100
mrMILO.king - blogskins.com/info/179001
i find the image rather confusing. i dont see how a girl drinking water relate to the title of your skin: LAST SUMMER i read the description saying about the greenhouse effect and all(im really glad you want to make people more aware about the situation) but seriously, i really cannot tell the message from the image! codings are okay, just that i think you should add a background colour and i find theres too many dashed borders used.
76/100
RulePlay - blogskins.com/info/179493
wow. i really love how you tried to blend the many pictures together! however, i find it too faded into the white background. maybe you could add more brushes or texture or perhaps colouring so that the image would have more strong colours so that it can stand out from the layout. i love the different shades of orange used in the codes, just that a border between the blog and the sidebar would be nice
79/100
paperlove - blogskins.com/info/179865
i love the pretty warm colours in the image. i think you should use a coloured background instead because white seems to make it look rather spacious and empty. codings are fine just that i think you should use maybe tahoma for the blogposts. i love the patterns, it kind of gives a vintage feel to it.
80/100
Hasegawa-San - blogskins.com/info/180096
hmm. interesting. the collage is nicely done but you could have sharpen the image more. you could have added a bit of brushes to beautify the image more. the codes are alright. im just not too sure about the purple headers.
74/100
thesockparody- - blogskins.com/info/180101
very nice choice of colours:. i truly adore the brushwork. however i cant really see the summer theme in the image (although i see a coconut tree there!). codes are fine, i especially love the blockquote background image.
79/100
rollercoaster.ride - blogskins.com/info/180128
i like the image. it shows what people would do in summer. codes are alright just that i wish you could squeeze in the disclaimer section into the white area or make the layout navigational. i dont really like the header font, maybe you could use lowercase georgia instead? but nice job on the whole.
81/100
Lady-Nadya - blogskins.com/info/180343
pretty image, love the brushes. cropping however can still be improved. take note of the background image, it repeats on the right in wider screen resolutions. set the background repeat to repeat-y. i wish you could alter the codes more because it looks too similar to kynzgerl's.
77/100
wat-u-wan-to-say - blogskins.com/info/181126
i dont like the font used in the image. overall is rather white and clean. i think you could have done more to the image. codes are alright just that maybe you could make the headers more interesting.
77/100
{/autumnlove - blogskins.com/info/181637
this skin has a very calm feeling to it. i like the sides of the image. i wish you could have done more to the codes though, its rather empty. you could have done more to the headers, colour/font etc. same goes for the blockquote. maybe add a background image?
78/100
tealightcandles - blogskins.com/info/182481
good effort. i like the quote in the image, its rather meaningful. you should add brushes into the image to make it more interesting. i dont like the blur of the edges and you could sharpen the whole thing more. codes are a bit dull though, its all grey with a touch of pink. add more colours to not just the codes but the image as well
74/100
XSTACY - blogskins.com/info/183041
i love the brushes used. i like the patterns and how you cropped the image but overall its a bit too messy for me.
i cant really see the summer theme only until i read the skin description! however i wish you could have
added summer-related quotes into the image. codes are alright in my opinion.
80/100
kissmylove} - blogskins.com/info/183495
oh my! the image is pretty i dont like the codes though especially the black background! the blogpost font is not the best choice.
tahoma is still probably the best choice. navigations can be abit bigger. anyway, nice job!
78/100
lix2004 - www.blogskins.com/info/183572
real unique! and its really colourful. i like the diary concept. the background is a bit plain. maybe you could add a background pattern or brushes?
83/100
Edited 15 days ago. |
| |
| |
|
| |
yeah. done.
but i still need to calculate the score.
done!
Edited 15 days ago. |
| |
| |
|
| |
i thought that there were more submissions.
|
| |
| |
|
| |
i edited those two due to some changes in comments that i got confused with.
|
| |
| |
|
| |
cushee } please see the reasons why i gave her such high marks...
|
| |
| |
|
| |
seriously don't bother making my award or anything this competition is so fucked up - -
I'm withdrawing. Sorry for any trouble.
Edited 15 days ago. |
| |
| |
|
| |
i thought here were alot of judges?
|
| |
| |
|
| |
oh, good the results are out
|
| |
| |
|
| |
Prima donna tantrum, huh?
|
| |
| |
|
| |
*surprised* wow 79 is too high. haha!
and omg 80+, u must be kidding me.
=]
gratz for the others!
|
| Subscribe To This Thread: RSS 2.0 or Atom (?) |
| You must be logged in to post comments. |
Home | Top Skins | All Skins | Tags | Forums | Contribute |
About
